Rhyme Time

Newt Eye : Fruit Pie : Mute Guy
Squeeze the juice of a newt eye into a fruit pie and turn talkers to mute guys..

Frog Gut : Dog Butt : Bog Mutt
One cup of frog gut rubbed on a dog's butt turns enemies to bog mutts..

Scum Slime : Some Time : Dumb Crime
Boil some scum slime and stir it for some time, and your rival will be arrestd for doing a dumb crime.